Tax on game? Anyone seen this book?

It is called Play Money

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465015352/104-5958100-5543164?v=glance&n=283155

I have not seen it referenced in forum yet, so sorry if I missed it.

I jumped ahead and read the last chapter…basically, the IRS has no rules for this stuff yet…big surprise there. Looks like an interesting read.

He makes reference to ND’s purchase (and PE) twice in the book…most references are for other mmorpgs.

ofc this would only be for us peeps
obviously every country has thier own tax system

its up to u if u decalre it or not

without a precedent in place u are at the will of whatever inspector looks at ur case

eg if ur investigated and they decide u have “earnings” then ofc all ernings are subject to a income tax, whereas another inspector may see it as “winnings” wich would be tax free here

its a new area and can change very quickly

persoanly i would seek experrt advice on the matter, book a hour with a tax specialist and get everything n writing, then ofc theres a trail of liability

cool , an other professor that never played PE and who will come explain me how to make money…

1 Like

http://www.wired.com/news/games/0,2101,63083,00.html

another article.

no, this guy was a player…who made thousands of dollars doing trades, then went to the IRS to find out if he needed to declare it and how. He played UO mostly, but is a mod (I think) on Terra Nova now…he also writs for a living (like in Wired).

He had a bet (described in the link), that he could make more money in a year from online gaming than from writing…but he failed (by about $600)…he only made about 47K in online gamming/trading.

He does have skillz…He does know stuff. He may get the IRS to take notice…though they have no clue what is happening in the online world…

as he says…what will they do?..make the game company’s send a 1099 (tax form) to ever player? :wink:

[QUOTE=Etopia]
cool , an other professor that never played PE and who will come explain me how to make money…
[/QUOTE]

lol :laugh:

“loot farmer” coun’t me in. I’m ordering it tomorrow.

:dance:

[QUOTE=Fade]
It is called Play Money

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465015352/104-5958100-5543164?v=glance&n=283155

I have not seen it referenced in forum yet, so sorry if I missed it.

I jumped ahead and read the last chapter…basically, the IRS has no rules for this stuff yet…big surprise there. Looks like an interesting read.

He makes reference to ND’s purchase (and PE) twice in the book…most references are for other mmorpgs.
[/QUOTE]

Infact, several places youll be needing to pay tax from loot.. If i make 10k USD the IRS dont give a fuck where i made it, they want their 30-or-so % and if you dont pay the tax? Up to 80% tax penalty.. Funfun!
Then of course come their problem. Proving that I made money. First they need to prove I made money and withdrew it, then they need to prove I made more than I deposited… Or actually, theire sleezy enough to have ME have to prove that I deposited…

[QUOTE=Fade]
as he says…what will they do?..make the game company’s send a 1099 (tax form) to ever player? :wink:
[/QUOTE]

really doesn’t matter what the source is, you can generally get away without declaring small amounts of income, but I gotta bet that ND is filling out that form. The only question I have is whether it is investment returns or gambling income?

[QUOTE=Fade]
http://www.wired.com/news/games/0,2101,63083,00.html

another article.

no, this guy was a player…who made thousands of dollars doing trades, then went to the IRS to find out if he needed to declare it and how. He played UO mostly, but is a mod (I think) on Terra Nova now…he also writs for a living (like in Wired).

He had a bet (described in the link), that he could make more money in a year from online gaming than from writing…but he failed (by about $600)…he only made about 47K in online gamming/trading.

He does have skillz…He does know stuff. He may get the IRS to take notice…though they have no clue what is happening in the online world…

as he says…what will they do?..make the game company’s send a 1099 (tax form) to ever player? :wink:
[/QUOTE]

Perhaps they might be able to do it for U.S companies. To other countries they can do nothing. Sorry to dissapoint you.

[QUOTE=Rumsponge]
really doesn’t matter what the source is, you can generally get away without declaring small amounts of income, but I gotta bet that ND is filling out that form. The only question I have is whether it is investment returns or gambling income?
[/QUOTE]

Investment returns. PE is not gambling. (Dont even start arguing that it is, cause if it where, it would be against swedish law. It may have similarities to a casino, but so do RL)

[QUOTE=Etopia]
cool , an other professor that never played PE and who will come explain me how to make money…
[/QUOTE]

JolanaKittyBrice?

The bulk of the book is about how he played his way to big money…it is only the last chapter where he deals with trying to figure out whether there is a tax liability.

I only bring the book up for community interest…and used the provocative title to get attention.

His point in the book…Even ND may not be liable right now for taxation…there are no rules on the books governing virtual items.

This is even more so, it it were a looted item (i.e. shadow armor)…as this is like finding $500 on the ground…and even then…it has no value outside of the game… The IRS simply has no rules covering these things…yet.

Books like this are going to raise the awareness though.

One of the author’s main points is that it is insane that he can earn more playing a game than a school teacher makes…it is a good point.

Maybe a smart school teacher would give her kids 30 minutes a day to do some skill grinding for her, so she can sell the avvy to compensate her income… I am sure the kids would not mind :wink:

I would suspect that tax liability isn’t incurred until you transfer your PEDs into USD as PEDs are not a currency recognized by any government. At the point that you make the transfer, any gains made from ingame activities are most likely taxable.

But I’m not a tax accountant, so this is all just speculation.

If they start taxing game in come, Ill be happy I lived long enough to see th day :wink:

I belive what rumsponge said is right regarding the PED not being taxable untill its moved to a RL bank account.

I do wonder how ND is going about it. I’m sure the IRS knows of his $100,000 purchase, and Im sure they wanna see if he starts making an income from it so they can get their share. Has ND even made enough of a withdraw from CND to care.

His personal business, but Im sure he is one person that has had to seriously investigated the implications of his investment to know what hes getting into…

Unless its all just an MA conspiracy theori :smiley:

Taxation…bah!

Wait until they realize money could be laundered and transferred over international borders! Resale on an LA could buy a lot of C-4 :slight_smile:

[QUOTE=Rumsponge]
I would suspect that tax liability isn’t incurred until you transfer your PEDs into USD as PEDs are not a currency recognized by any government. At the point that you make the transfer, any gains made from ingame activities are most likely taxable.

[/QUOTE]

Does this mean I can claim a tax rebate on my deposits, I certainly don’t make any profit :laugh:

In the United States they CAN tax your earnings from PE/EU. I point you to the 16th Amendment →

At the heart of the brouhaha is the 16th Amendment to the Constitution, adopted in 1913, which established a federal income tax.

Its full text is:

“The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census of enumeration.”

[QUOTE=Faustian]
In the United States they CAN tax your earnings from PE/EU. I point you to the 16th Amendment →

At the heart of the brouhaha is the 16th Amendment to the Constitution, adopted in 1913, which established a federal income tax.

Its full text is:

“The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census of enumeration.”
[/QUOTE]

Lets turn the tables here for a second.

If this happened, would you be able to claim deposits as business expenses? After all, you are putting forth funds as an investment hoping for a return. I’m sure it works both ways, so if they are going to start taxing you for what you MAKE, they had better start compensating you for what you INVEST.

[QUOTE=Metatron]
Lets turn the tables here for a second.

If this happened, would you be able to claim deposits as business expenses? After all, you are putting forth funds as an investment hoping for a return. I’m sure it works both ways, so if they are going to start taxing you for what you MAKE, they had better start compensating you for what you INVEST.
[/QUOTE]

This would fall under the category of lets say winning the lottery. Yes you could claim your deposits, but only if you claim your winnings. And you can only claim up to what you’ve won.

Sucks but thats the way it works.

yep, the cost of lottery tickets/ammo/probes can only be deducted from the income derived from that venture. But that is true of business expenses, too.