Quest for Clarity: The $165M Question

I sent an email to the author of the press release…the ball is in MA’s court…


Hi (Frigid),

The $165,000,000 US dollars figure was given to me by MindArk. They quoted that statistic themselves as it being actually US dollars and not PED – so I am trusting that they have their figures right. ;-). If you think about it in terms of how many players Entropia has (estimated 470,000 members), the figure really only equates to about $350 a year per person. (given my math is right).

That being said, money laundering is not the case here. But I can see how a number this high can raise eyebrows. I would say simply attribute it to the success of the game thanks to its loyal members.

Hope this answers your question.

Thanks!

Jackie

Jackie Lacambra

Senior Account Executive

TERPIN COMMUNICATIONS

4333 Admiralty Way East Tower Suite 200

Marina Del Rey, CA 90292

(310) 821-6100 x108

jackie@terpin.com


From: (Frigid)
Sent: Tuesday, August 08, 2006 10:15 AM
To: jackie@terpin.com
Subject: A bit of clarification on the Entropia Universe press release

Jackie,

I am a player in the Entropia Universe and I read the press release:

http://www.marketwire.com/mw/release_html_b1?release_id=151156

While I do enjoy anything that brings recognition to the game, I can’t get my head around this quote:

"In 2005, the Entropia Universe turnover (amount of virtual Project Entropia Dollars converted back into real world currency) was estimated at $165,000,000 US dollars.”

I know you have a disclaimer on the accuracy of the facts, but I just want to make sure there was not some oversight in the units. In the games, we deal with PEDs (Project Entropia Dollars) and they are 1/10th the value of one dollar. Is it possible the 165 Million was not dollars but actually PEDs? Swedes use commas as decimals and vice-versa, perhaps some confusion there?

$165M USD is a huge sum and many players (including myself ) are trying to come to grips with how this could be. Based upon the dealings within the game, this just seems an unlikley amount of money to be turned into real cash from our game. I can only hope money is not being “laundered” through EU!

I thank you in advance for any light you can shed on this issue,

Best Regards,

(Frigid)


So…tell me when Marco gets back :wink:

4 Likes

You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to Frigid again.

1 Like

its just marketing hyperbole. turnover is not money in or even earnt, its literally the money turned over in the game. example, buy 10ped ammo, expend it and loot 10ped (i wish!), use that to buy an item off another avatar who then buys 10ped of ammo and expends. you’ve just turned over 30ped of economic activity.

or to put it another way, $165m is more than all combined deposits ever made into PE.

turnover

I’m not a native english speaker, but… could it be that the main difference relies in how they define the word “turnover” ?.

When I saw these figures in EU’s web site, I understood by “turnover” as the money that is “recycled”, as a measure of the ammount of business being made in game, including money spent, items bought, loots awarded, items traded, and so on… To me, it means how much money is “moved” in EU. Which is totally different to the ammount of money that is withdrawed from the game.

If we do the maths for 165M$, this is 1,650 Mped a year; it would mean roughly 4.5 Mped a day. If we assume (roughly again) 10k daily active players, this would mean 450 ped recycled, in average, per player, daily.
Sounds not too unreasonable to me…

Just a thought,
/jdegre.

Edit: What FlashHarry said… :slight_smile:

Turnover in European accounting means “revenue”, so if they count revenue as any cash inflows into the game, then $165MM over a year is pretty healthy, but again, this is not their profit nor the money withdrawn, just the cash equivalent of funds tied into game.

[QUOTE=Frigid]
I sent an email to the author of the press release…the ball is in MA’s court…


Hi (Frigid),

The $165,000,000 US dollars figure was given to me by MindArk. They quoted that statistic themselves as it being actually US dollars and not PED – so I am trusting that they have their figures right. ;-). If you think about it in terms of how many players Entropia has (estimated 470,000 members), the figure really only equates to about $350 a year per person. (given my math is right).
[/QUOTE]

The problem here is the number of players is assumed.
20% of that number are probably multiple accounts and a further25% are inactive.

[QUOTE=wanda]
The problem here is the number of players is assumed.
20% of that number are probably multiple accounts and a further25% are inactive.
[/QUOTE]

Its something I’m trying to calculate based on a few sources like the financials and a few statements MA has made in the past. I think the churn rate of new accounts is enormous.

[QUOTE=Kombinator]
Turnover in European accounting means “revenue”, so if they count revenue as any cash inflows into the game, then $165MM over a year is pretty healthy, but again, this is not their profit nor the money withdrawn, just the cash equivalent of funds tied into game.
[/QUOTE]

This is interesting. Thanks for the insights on terms. If the line had said, "In 2005, the Entropia Universe turnover was estimated at $165,000,000 US dollars.” I would look at it exactly as you explained. However, it is the “(amount of virtual Project Entropia Dollars converted back into real world currency)” which is supposed to define that turnover that gets me.

I read this, and re-read this and always I get the same impression that 1.65 Billion PEDs were converted into $165 Million USD, worth of real world currency and taken out of the game. Spin? Hype? How else can I read this?

The author says MA gave her these numbers, now to follow-up with MA. I still think there is a crossed wire somewhere, and this number is just a misunderstanding. But…if MA is throwing out this number like they throw around the 470K member number, I’d like to know how it was derived. The 470K members is easy…count the number of accounts registered. The $165M is still hard for me to grasp…

Aha!

Ok…it does seem to be a misunderstanding:

from the report below (thanks Asti for the link!):

MA 2005 Annual Report

we find on page 7:

Development and continuity
MindArk has grown consistently since then.The planet Calypso
has been constantly developed.A measure of how well the new
planet was received can be seen in Calypsos GNP during 2005,
which amounted to over 1.65 Billion PED (165 million USD).

GNP is defined as(more or less varying with context):

The total value of all goods and services produced by a country’s citizens during a period of time, usually one year.

This means that all of our transactions and production is tracked and tallied for the GNP. I am unsure if this is TT or market values, but I am guessing market values apply.

So, this is NOT money converted to real currency…

…hold your breath for the retraction :wink:

[QUOTE=wanda]
The problem here is the number of players is assumed.
20% of that number are probably multiple accounts and a further25% are inactive.
[/QUOTE]

I would say it’s alot higher then that! I have 2 accounts my self, one is my wifes who never plays, and, actualy have forgotten the login and pass for it. I could give 1000 examples of those I know. Some having 5 some having 10. So I would speculate, the number is probably 50% inaccurate. Plus there probably still counting accounts that are banned. Juts like here on EF, it still counts banned accounts. My opinion 50% of that number have actual accounts, and probably 50% of that number actualy plays. And 50% of that number actualy plays on a weekly basis. And probably 50% of the original tried i for a week and will never return.

Just how I see :smiley: I could be wrong. If MA lets be peruse there records i could give a more definitive answer.

Although MA obviously played on people misinterpreting what they mean with “turnover”, it’s not that hard to figure out (and is the responsibility of the reader) they did not intent it as meaning cash being converted from PED<->$. They do after all ‘consider’ the ingame economics for being equivalent to a real world economic system, so it should be natural for them to use such terms.

[QUOTE=Faustian]
I would say it’s alot higher then that! I have 2 accounts my self, one is my wifes who never plays, and, actualy have forgotten the login and pass for it. I could give 1000 examples of those I know. Some having 5 some having 10. So I would speculate, the number is probably 50% inaccurate. Plus there probably still counting accounts that are banned. Juts like here on EF, it still counts banned accounts. My opinion 50% of that number have actual accounts, and probably 50% of that number actualy plays. And 50% of that number actualy plays on a weekly basis. And probably 50% of the original tried i for a week and will never return.

Just how I see :smiley: I could be wrong. If MA lets be peruse there records i could give a more definitive answer.
[/QUOTE]

WTF???, is anyone actually left playing? :smiley:

+rep sent to jdegre:

[QUOTE=jdegre]

To me, it means how much money is “moved” in EU. Which is totally
different from the ammount of money that is withdrawn from the game.

If we do the maths for 165M$, this is 1,650 Mped a year; it would mean roughly 4.5 Mped a day. If we assume (roughly again) 10k daily active players, this would mean 450 ped recycled, in average, per player, daily.
Sounds not too unreasonable to me…

[/QUOTE]

Yes, let’s assume 7k-13k active players and about 300 active gamedays
per year (for those average players … :girl: ) and we get:

165MUSD * 10 PED/USD / ( 7000…13000 player * 300 day) =
785…425 PED / (player * day)

One could comfortably state that a turnover per gaming day is
about 400…800 PEDs. The usual turnover factor (the ratio
between turnover and “PEDs forever lost by player” seems to be
highly varying, for me it is about 4.0 and for most it is 3.0…20.0 .
That comes from my queries about how friends play and about
my own bookkeeping (not everyday, just samples).

Let’s state that factor is K hehe. Then:

425…785 PED / 3.0 … 20.0 = 21…260 PED

That figure would be the estimated cost of play per person per day.
So, one could say EU costs 2..25 USD per day.

The figures above can be made little more exact by checking
the actual deposits over year from the MA annual report (I don’t
bother to check it nw):

K = turnover / all_deposits

Naturally K varies highly by the profession and the play style. For me
it is about 4 though.

Some numbers from reality…

[QUOTE=wanda]
The problem here is the number of players is assumed.
20% of that number are probably multiple accounts and a further25% are inactive.
[/QUOTE]

If you want real numbers, you have to read PR… not PR for attracting customers, but PR/information for convincing Investors. Since I am gathering information about MA and EU (and other games like that) for an article in a major german computer-magazine, covering the whole onlinegames-story from the point of customers, I found for example this: Bridge Investor Express 08/2005(PDF)

MA giving information to attract Investors, even an interview with JWT. For example:

  • they will raise the money spend: 500k Euro for game developement, 500k Euro for handling customers, and 1.5M Euro for PR.
  • their PR-focus will be on germany and holland.
  • 70% of new customers never log in again after just one month.
  • 25% of customers staying in EU start depositing.
  • 600 players are usually online at the same time, including bots, resellers, …

Happy reading. :slight_smile:

Lex (ex Jac )

1 Like

$165,000,000.00 in withdrawls.
470,000 registered accounts.

devide $165,000,000.00 by 470,000 and you get $351 withdrawn per player.

Clearly if all players were withdrawing rather than depositing, there would be no money to withdraw.

If one, and one only, avatar withdrew all that, then all the other players would have to put in $351/year each to raise that amount.

If half the players (235,000) withdrew it between them, (IE they are running at a profit, and are not depositing) then theose who are depositing would have to deposit $702/year to cover it ($165mil/235k).

If half the members are inactive, then thats $1404/year deposited per player (165mil/117,500) to raise that amount.

Hype? possibley.
Some land-owners making a huge profit? potentially.
MA got it’s sums wrong… :silly2:

Make of it what you will.
I am not sure if they are not actually telling the truth, and that a small number of players did actually withdraw it (all $165,000,000.00), and smiled all they way to their new yaht and Mazarati, care of us.

MA charge a handeling fee on withdrawls. What would MA’s cut of the $165,000,000.00 have been? 10% is it not? Nice tidy profit for MA that, $16,500,000.00.

[QUOTE=LexLooter]

MA giving information to attract Investors, even an interview with JWT. For example:

  • they will raise the money spend: 500k Euro for game developement, 500k Euro for handling customers, and 1.5M Euro for PR.
  • their PR-focus will be on germany and holland.
  • 70% of new customers never log in again after just one month.
  • 25% of customers staying in EU start depositing.
  • 600 players are usually online at the same time, including bots, resellers, …
    )
    [/QUOTE]

Interesting post and 70% is a huge churn rate :eek: Also something to be said of the 80/20 rule for the deposits, that 20% of the population is depositing 80% of the wealth.

[QUOTE=Aziphirael]
Interesting post and 70% is a huge churn rate :eek: Also something to be said of the 80/20 rule for the deposits, that 20% of the population is depositing 80% of the wealth.
[/QUOTE]

And ouch being one of them :wise:

[QUOTE=Dorsai]
$165,000,000.00 in withdrawls.
470,000 registered accounts.

devide $165,000,000.00 by 470,000 and you get $351 withdrawn per player.

Clearly if all players were withdrawing rather than depositing, there would be no money to withdraw.

If one, and one only, avatar withdrew all that, then all the other players would have to put in $351/year each to raise that amount.

If half the players (235,000) withdrew it between them, (IE they are running at a profit, and are not depositing) then theose who are depositing would have to deposit $702/year to cover it ($165mil/235k).

If half the members are inactive, then thats $1404/year deposited per player (165mil/117,500) to raise that amount.

Hype? possibley.
Some land-owners making a huge profit? potentially.
MA got it’s sums wrong… :silly2:

Make of it what you will.
I am not sure if they are not actually telling the truth, and that a small number of players did actually withdraw it (all $165,000,000.00), and smiled all they way to their new yaht and Mazarati, care of us.

MA charge a handeling fee on withdrawls. What would MA’s cut of the $165,000,000.00 have been? 10% is it not? Nice tidy profit for MA that, $16,500,000.00.
[/QUOTE]

$165m is not what have been withdrawn, its this games total gnp ^^

I think that where we all have a problem is in the phrase “converted back into real world currency”. As I see it, should be read “total PEDS spent ingame was 1.6 bilion in 2005, which, if we make calculation at PED/$ rate, means 165M $”.

For me, that “converted back” doesn’t mean the specific amount of PEDs was withdrawn, but it means that the specific numbers of PEDs would equal this given number of real world currency.

As in “if my cat would drink 700 litres of water, would weight ~705 kg”. But the fact is my cat pee back in nature most of that water.

1 Like

[QUOTE=LexLooter]
Since I am gathering information about MA and EU (and other games like that) for an article in a major german computer-magazine, covering the whole onlinegames-story from the point of customers
[/QUOTE]

Do you promise to write all about the slow, copy&paste and unhelpful MA Support ? :slight_smile:
It is the most annoying thing in the whole game, even the 2 old year bugs are less disturbing…