Note over societies.

Hi :slight_smile:

I know that there are many, many soc leaders or aspirant soc leaders that want to get the biggest soc, the fastest possible.

Just a little note to help them:

Storm-Recruiting (asking everyone that simply passes in front of you), withouth no requirements, or even knowing a little the person, only leads a soc down to the cliff :wink:

I am saying this because I see many, many soc leaders that wants to have big, big socs over 100 members, in about a week or two of existence.

Another note: kicking a member straightly, withouth even discussing with him, about the reasons you are going to kick him, only gets you more s***.

I am saying this because I saw a lot of disturbment in societies like NBK recently, 3 members arbitrarly kicked, I dont want to comment this, but this means those 3 members are going to do bad publicity.

Just my twopecs :slight_smile:

I hope those little notes will help society leaders :slight_smile:

And don’t ask me why i’m Freelancer :wink:

EDIT: Woops, thought I was in SocTalk channel
Could a moderator move the topic please?

1 Like

You make some good points. I don’t think any serious society uses the storm-recruiting tactic though, that would just be stupid. What you get with that tactic is a whole bunch of newbies, probably around 70% inactive such. :wink:

I can’t see the point of having such a big society of like 100 people either. It’s impossible to get to know all of them and also keep track of them. I don’t even wanna think of how the soc chat will look with constant chatter and no peace.

I have kicked members without discussing it with them and I still do. To my defence they have all been inactive and I just can’t wait a month or two in hope that they will come back so I can tell 'em they’re out. :laugh:

Yea, of course it’s totally another matter if the person is inactive :wink:

First off there are wayyyyyyyyyyy too many societies. Noobs are creating them. There sould be a skill level on a person pefore they go making a society. Maybe like 2K in skills then you are permitted to create one. Half the socieies are filled with inacive memebers. I think there should be a built in system to remove them. If you are inactive 30 days you get removed out of the society.

Or maybe mindARK could charge 25 ped to create a soceity. Something to bring the numbers down. Then after 6 months of your society being active you would receive the 25 ped back.

1 Like

If they charge 25peds to make a society, I guess they wont give them to you back :nana:

About the skill limit, I totally agree to this. :slight_smile:

Agreed, you shouldn’t be able to create a society after being here for a week. i want to see great societies with experienced members helping out the new guys. Either a skill cap or a one-off fee sound good to me.

How true,

we in the JB have had a lot of inactives, Enum has whittled them away
and all that are left are regular players. :wink:
Now we have a log in on our website to allow leaders easy checking of activity. (Even if members are away from EU on holiday for example)

Recruiting new members is hard, as serious (above 2k skills) players are either in Socs or dedicated freelancers.

p.s. MK, if you are interested in joining a soc…

Stinky :silly2:

I disagree totally with such a limit Mr. Tha BiGG DoGG.
Regarding skills I am a noob by all means,
so it would have been impossible for me to found the Federation of Free Wanderers.

You seem to believe that a noob is a bad person.

But why should anybody managing to convince enough people for qualifying in the pending period meet any more requirements?
What I could agree with is that the qualification period would be raised to 2 weeks and the necessary members to 10,
but if MindArk allows for 5 people societies it is their decision.

What I very well could understand and would support (if it is not existing yet) is that societies falling below the member limit are set to a recovering period of maybe a month or even less and then get deleted, when not raising enough members again in that period of time.

And regarding societies that are pending - well there is a reason that this status is shown, so no bad done in having lots and lots of pending societies, or do I miss something here?

Regards
P. Danford

1 Like

[QUOTE=Hrafninn]
I can’t see the point of having such a big society of like 100 people either. It’s impossible to get to know all of them and also keep track of them. I don’t even wanna think of how the soc chat will look with constant chatter and no peace.
[/QUOTE]

I used to be a member of Fallen Angels next Generation (FAnG) (R.I.P.). We only had around 12-15ish active members. I absolutely loved the size. It was perfect to have peace but at the same time have a good group of friends hunt with.

I can’t imagine ever joining or starting a soc with over… say… 25 members tops. I just like a small close knit group. Its just better that way. (who wants to be on the largest soc list, anyway? :eek: Not I!)

And yeah, I have had like three socs just ask to join at PA without even chatting with me in the past week. Grrr. No, I WONT join. :umn: Thats just not the way to recruit. Its asking for failure.

I agree with the “too many socs in eu” idea.

I think there are alot of people that start societys because they want to be the “boss” and leader. I can say from observation, discussion, and experience that running a society is not easy and take alot of time and effort. Its a sacrafice of the leader to keep things organized and co-ordinated. Some people forget to take this into account. Member retention is often overlooked and people focus on recruiting.

Also I belive some people make socs so they can have a title above their head. Some “wannabe” scammers also try to make themself more legit to noobs.

The skill idea to start a soc is a good one but at the same time i do know that FoF and TV might not have been here had the skill limit been set too high. If someone has the drive and DEDICATION to run a society, in-game skills are not the most inportant me thinks.

I would say a PED charge, would be good. Heck many goverments large and small have “processing fees” or “application fees” to do paperwork. For permits and various other docs. This would discourage the fly by night socs and show the more serious people interested in running an organization.

Also there are people out there that just want to make it to the to 50 most populated socs too :wink:

all this is just my opinion of course. :slight_smile:

1 Like

as this thread goes, more people say i want a soc with less then 25 people in it…thats why we have so many societies! in TIG we are up to about 20 last i checked and all of them are awsome, and i think if it went up to 50 maybe more id still say awsome as it seems the only people that join TIG are people like me/the other members and we all fit very well. joining a soc thats large could be cool… massive events i would hope…as for a mid sized (25-50?) i think is a very cool place to be. and creates an activity that you dont want to miss causing you to be on more. as for leaders you need a leader that leads but still plays with ya, just like the boss IRL.

The NBK Army for a while had 200 players, much of whom were inactive, and now is down to around 100 players that r all active. its a great number b/c there r always ppl on to answer questions, hunt with, or just talk to. Also not everyone in the soc is on at the same time. there r usually about 20-25 players on and only 10-15 that actually use the soc chat.

IMO there shouldn’t be any skill limit. in terms of skills there could be a player who has played for 4 months and has only sweated and traded. then they have almost no skills but they r not noobs. they know the game and the market well but they dont have good skills.

Going from the above post ^ would not a time limit be more fitting?

[QUOTE=Stinky]
How true,

we in the JB have had a lot of inactives, Enum has whittled them away
and all that are left are regular players. :wink:
[/QUOTE]

hehe :sniper:

…and yes I too agree with the thread creator. Except maybe for kicking people without talking with them first. If someone goes inactive then it’s kindof hard to talk with them first before kicking them. I also wish MA would show soc leaders when their members last logged into EU. Because it’s easy to think someone is inactive when they actually are loging in for an hour or so when I may be asleep at 4am!

To help resolve this I created a website and require all members to log into the site once every two weeks, otherwise their name goes on an inactives list that all other members can see (this way other members don’t freak out and wonder why someone was kicked). Then if another week or so goes by and I still cant contact the member they get kicked. Anyone I kick for being inactive is welcome to reapply, and they will get their old rank back as long as the meet the current requirements for that rank.

I’m not sure if any of this will really work in the long run. I was sort of “handed” the General title after our old leader was voted out, and then the new leader quit a month later. :\

So my goal is to try and restore JB to its former glory…I will certainly try my best! :wink:

1 Like

Enum, you misundertood what I said :wink:

Actually, Im thinking kicking withouth talking with the person is rude, and actually produces even more fresh dung for you :laugh:

When the person is inactive for many months, then yea, you can kick him/her :girl:

That’s what I think

Who the hell cares how many societies there are? What difference does it make?

Would you rather these noobs all stand around in atlantis all day with nothing to do? Or make a soc, team up, and go have fun?

I agree with alot of the opinions and ideas excpressed in this thread.

It think that ther are far too many socs in the soc term and a large majority of them i never see in any towns anywhere.
That makes me think that a large majority of the socs listed there are inactive and defunct were the members have all quit or rarely log on.
Those inactive socs should be purged. It seems in some cases they are inactive because the creater or leader stopped logging on, was banned or is made of noobs who all quit. In somecases resulting in a bunch of 1 man socs.

I also think that there should be more requirements in creating a soc. requirements for keeping one, as well as an activity requirement for the leader.
Perhaps a skill requirement and/or time/activity requirement to create one along with some kinda fee.
There are other virtual universes (games) where there is a fee needed to create a guild/soc/community/faction/etc., we should have one too.

For here a requirement of a skill threshold OR time/activity requirement.
Where the skill requirement be somewhere around what is needed to graduate an descipleship and for the trader socs or people that dont participate in skill gaining activities a time and activity requirement in leu of a skill requirement.
That way a dedicated person who really wants to have a soc can still do so and yet ensure that their soc would be a benefit to EU instead of wasted resources and space.

I too wish there was a way that a soc leader can know when the last time and duration of when a member has logged in in order to more fairly and efficiently enforce activity requirements.
This function should be available only to the leader and administrative ranks of a soc.

As far as larege socs go i agreee that the blitzkrieg/shotgun approach to recruiting is a method that invites disaster.
Yet poses a unique challenge to someone who wants to create and be involved in a large one.
Large socs have thier advantages especially for a newb soc as it creates alot of rescources for info. While the soc chat will be constantly going you also have acess to someone who can answer a question or give assistance anywhere in EU.
The drawback is the management nightmare of trying to keep the bad apples like scammers and arseholes out and helpful team oriented people in.
A good soc does not even need to recruit as they would have people lining up to join

I think that the NBK group is one of the best examples of a successful large soc. If NBK keeps going on the path hey are on they very well might be the first soc to be in the top 10 for both skills and size.

Creating a soc is an act that should not be taken lighly and should not be done on a whim.
It is a big responsability that takes some work and dedication.
The soc your in can have a great impact on how people treat you and the respect you get.
Bad leadership can result in a los of respect for every member of the soc.
BAHQ is an example of that. in the past they had some bad apples that messed things up for everyone. That has and is changing, they have lots of new blood and new leadership and thier image is making a great comeback.
This applies to real life as well but i wont go into the real life examples of bad real life socs :slight_smile:

Anyway the point is the soc system seems to be broken and needs some reletively minor changes both to elimiate frivilous creation of socs as well as giving existing socs more tools to make managing a soc easier

You can’t compare other MMO’s guild system fees to Project Entropia.

Entropia is real $$$, GuildWar is 30mins mob camping.

I would hate to be in a soc with a hundred or so members, many of whom are active - it would be too much of a chatfest and the person-person rapport would get lost. It would be necessary to use PM’s a lot more to maintain the older relationships and would undermine much of what is good about being in a soc.

By the same token, there are far too many socs that seem to exist in name only, with 1 or 2 regular members - the rest long turned inactive. The worst abuse of the soc system is the occasion when I have seen noobs being the Master of socs called ‘PLEASE HELP A POOR NOOB’, though it is kind of funny :laugh:

Why can’t a soc be ushered into oblivion if the level of activity falls below a certain level? Say less than 3 members active inside a 2 month period - this might reintroduce some meaning into the concept.

A side aspect of this would be to introduce some kind of service tag alonsgside the soc name - say a bar for 3 months in soc, 2 bars for 6 and so on..a visible sense of the member’s actual involvement in a society and of the society itself in EU

[QUOTE=Mkdesign]
You can’t compare other MMO’s guild system fees to Project Entropia.

Entropia is real $$$, GuildWar is 30mins mob camping.
[/QUOTE]

wich means the person making the soc, and the society its self is more serious. Not just a flake.

Kinda like RL. atleast in the US i know for sure, if you want to make a corperation or a non-profit organization (church, charity, research) there are forms and applications to file. (creating soc at soc term) then you have to wait to be approved and get your papers (ATM you need 8 members and ?? days, then MA says ok) and then in some cases every year or every few years you need to renew those papers. I dont see why in EU that would be bad.

Heck, here I even need a permit just to put up a sign visible to the public if its in a commercial area…and dont get me started on sings and residential, even if its a house for sale sign :laugh:

And i also would like to have a note in the soc term to see when members were last active.

And I would also like to see a society reputation system…but thats another thing and so open to abuse :rolleyes: