Just a quick poll to see if people would be interested in a lowest unique bid for uber items - I am not sure if you have seen these on flights but the lowest unique bid on an item wins it. http://www.bidclever.com/ is an example of what I am on about - Reverse Auctions
just thinking of ways of the majoraty of people been able to get something excellent in a lottery type way rather than looting - with say a limit of 100 of these auctions per year so items still stay unique.
Ideas for items in the Reverse Auction could be or what ever people wanted.
Land Area with taxation rights
Hanger
Full Shadow F / M
RIGHT - LISTEN CAREFULLY AS YOU HAVER NOT GRASPED THE IDEA AT ALL -
You go to an auctionear and pay them 10 ped - this 10 ped then allows you to enter 1 Bid on the item in question.
If you want to enter another bid you pay another 10 ped for 1 more bid
When all the allocated tickets / Minimum bids to cover the cost the Item the LOWEST UNIQUE BID WINS not a bid of 1 pec as thats DUMB
Oh I BET 1 PEc = NO if 2 people bid 1 pec its NOT A WINNING BID
So If there were 1000 Bidders then it would be the LOWEST UNIQUE BID out of those 1000 this could be an amount any where realistically between 1 - 1000 . BUT ALL BIDDERS HAVE PAID 10 PED PER BID
BIDS TO BE WHOLE PEDS - Just like a win a car @ airport thing or these auctions on aircraft -there is some skill of guessing the bid to win and so isnt a lottery.
EXAMPLE
Jim, Bob, Sally and Paul all play.
Jim Bids 5 peds
Bob Bids 2 peds
Sally Bids 1 peds
Paul Bids 1 peds
Because 2 people bidded the same, that bid is not unique anymore, so the winner is Bob, because no one else bidded 2 peds, other than him.
bob has paid 12 ped for a really cool item - others have lost there 10 peds to pay for the item
Iām not sure if this idea makes sense or not. To me, it sounds like you are suggesting that hundreds upon hundreds of people would be bidding, or donating, towards this cause. the cause being sort of an āUber Stuff for Noobersā fund. Each donation you make gets you what? A raffle ticket in which a name is drawn and you either win or lose?
If this is the case, how do you make that effectively reasonable for a noob, or even not so noob, player to have a real chance? Is there a limit on the amount of entries into the drawing that they can purchase? Who decides the winner? How do you determine the winner if it isnāt a random lottery.
Maybe you should just create more of a random lottery system. Let people purchase tickets and select their lottery numbers. 5 or 6 numbers from 1 to 60. For each lottery , determine the prize ahead of time and then once the drawing date has arrived, you pull 6 numbers (or 5) out of the hopper and if someone has those numbers, they win. If not, no one wins the item and it just builds towards the next bigger drawing.
I think it is a good idea, in its basic form, but sounds to me like we need to work out some of the details before you start getting people excited about this sort of thing.
I voted no, but I would like it to happen. Reason I did indeed vote NO is that, I doubt its legal according to EULA to sell something with outside-of-game currency. Thats like if one sells 100k ped for $10k for saving MAās deduction tax.
Edited top message to give a clearer idea of reverse auction.
A reverse auction is an auction with a difference, where people can buy goods such as cars, consumer electronics and holidays for pennies! Registered users pay to enter an auction - Their aim? To outwit fellow bidders by placing what they think will be the lowest unique bid. You could be driving away in a brand new car⦠all for pennies
[QUOTE=Sal]
Edited top message to give a clearer idea of reverse auction.
A reverse auction is an auction with a difference, where people can buy goods such as cars, consumer electronics and holidays for pennies! Registered users pay to enter an auction - Their aim? To outwit fellow bidders by placing what they think will be the lowest unique bid. You could be driving away in a brand new car⦠all for pennies
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=heehaw]
i like that idea but some people will indeed be pissed that someone out there just got a land area for⦠lets say a piece of dung? :laugh:
[/QUOTE]
Oh yea⦠I would maybe (dont want to make it unique vs un-unique) bid an bottle of sweat then
Voted ānoā since I donāt like this kind of āauctionā. In RL itās most commonly used for ācompetitionsā with an almost scam-like revenue.
These events are usually marketed as great things where people have a good chance of getting really valuable items very cheap. But in reality, itās more like a lottery, where the total amount of money paid for the prize are 10 or 100 times the value of the prize.
Ofc it doesnāt HAVE to be like that⦠but:
[QUOTE=Sal]
ā¦and then after the promotion has run long enough to cover the cost of the item the lowest unique auction bid ont he item wins itā¦
[/QUOTE]
Who decides when the auctioneer has made enough money and the auction ends? Or is it within a certain timeframe? The rules should certainly be public⦠Otherwise I believe it would brake swedish law.
[QUOTE=Sal]
ā¦just thinking of ways of the majoraty of people been able to get something excellent in a lottery type way rather than lootingā¦
[/QUOTE]
Yes⦠You said it. Itās really a lottery. I highly doubt that MA will want to support in EU.
Sry to be so negative⦠I try so hard not to be, but always fails miserably. :laugh:
Sounds fun, never heard of this way of auctioning before. Ofc the bids must be made secret⦠And thats the only problem with this since there would be needed some trust, (so the auctioneer doesnt just give it to a friend even tho he didnt win, etc.)
Ofc, all bids could be accepted until a certain date, then a post would be made with the names of the bidders and the bids they placed, showing the bids in order, and the not unique bids marked in red and the winner in green for example..
but then again the auctioneer may have put a friends name in a winners spot without the other players knowledge. hmm.. tricky.
but yes, there is some gambling and lottery factors to it⦠so probably illegeal!
[QUOTE=Skam]
Sounds fun, never heard of this way of auctioning before. Ofc the bids must be made secret⦠And thats the only problem with this since there would be needed some trust, (so the auctioneer doesnt just give it to a friend even tho he didnt win, etc.)
Ofc, all bids could be accepted until a certain date, then a post would be made with the names of the bidders and the bids they placed, showing the bids in order, and the not unique bids marked in red and the winner in green for example..
but then again the auctioneer may have put a friends name in a winners spot without the other players knowledge. hmm.. tricky.
[/QUOTE]
Its a software thing I could easily build into www.kn00b.com/stats/ if people wants to set an exact timeframe and ignore same amounts of bidsā¦
I would just have to understand it totally firstā¦
2 bids of example 1.39 reset each others, but if an 3rd guy bids 1.39 hes back on track?
I would agrea that there would need to be some trust in this - thats why If there are enough yes votes I would put it to MA for a suggestion either to go in to the auctions or as a new use for the voting terminals maybe I would not want to run it from a forum as this may appear to be a scam & MA have auctions in place and so could in theorey mofdify stuff.
the bids would be secret so no one knew what there bid is it is the LOWEST UNIQUE bid that wins and depending on the item = amount of tickets needed to be sold with tickets remaining for the item displayed in the window.
I would say that there should be a 20% abouve the tt price of the equipment profit to go to MA that would then in turn go back to the loot system & MA could have special items. yes if there are 1000 tickets in thearoy the lowest unique bid could be 999 ped - but then if that was a land area maybe it would still be worth it
Or Maybe see if they could trial it for a VU and see if people play I would say its more of a competition / auction than a lottery and so would depend how MA / EU law approved of this.
Since i didnt read all replies iāll just write what i think.
This could be a nice thing, and also legal as it is not a lottery. It is considered to be like any other auction actually.
This is exactly how it works.
You pay a sum of for example 10 ped to be able to post a bid.
For example you bid on 30 ped for a shadow helmet, and you pay
the 10 ped fee. Then you would get a notification if your bid is the lowest unique bid or if it is just a unique bid or not and if it has uniqe lower bids under it.
If you then want to you can bid on more bids if you want to try to either remowe the other uniqe ones so yours become the lowest one and so on. This continues until a set date or until the auction has paid off and then the lowest uniqe bid wins and have to pay that bid.
This is how it works and itās totally legal as it is not considered a lottery
[QUOTE=Vedder]
Voted ānoā since I donāt like this kind of āauctionā. In RL itās most commonly used for ācompetitionsā with an almost scam-like revenue.
These events are usually marketed as great things where people have a good chance of getting really valuable items very cheap. But in reality, itās more like a lottery, where the total amount of money paid for the prize are 10 or 100 times the value of the prize.
Ofc it doesnāt HAVE to be like that⦠but:
Who decides when the auctioneer has made enough money and the auction ends? Or is it within a certain timeframe? The rules should certainly be public⦠Otherwise I believe it would brake swedish law.
Yes⦠You said it. Itās really a lottery. I highly doubt that MA will want to support in EU.
Sry to be so negative⦠I try so hard not to be, but always fails miserably. :laugh:
[/QUOTE]
I try to think as positive as possible ⦠but this kind of āauctionā is just terrible and I agree 100% with youāre ānegativeā post. And the reason why:
Iāve noticed and followed (not actively) these kind of āauctionsā in RL. If you want to place a bid you have to pay a fee (say 1 euro). Then youāll receive a message which notifies you about:
if your bid is unique
if your bid is the lowest
In RL itās very easy to ignore. I donāt want the crap they sell. I donāt want to gamble. I donāt have a mobile phone needed to place a bid. I donāt want to make the people behind it rich.
Apon that: I wonāt know who won and I wonāt get to be reminded about it every time.
In EU this will be different. I would like to have uberstuff. And the winner will most likely be known here, making it much harder for me to ignore this crap.
Away with this scamlike auction! :deal: :cowboy: :deal: